Friday, November 13, 2015

Reaction to the Charlie Hebdo Massacre, Part One

How's this for a thought experiment about irreverence:

Serial is the worst piece of trash disguised as journalism to be produced in recent years. The show presents itself as searching for the truth by applying a generic veneer of liberal progressivism when in reality Serial is all about ratings, ratings, and more ratings. The producers behind the show are unethical and are using the murder of a young woman purely for entertainment.

I'm serious when I say that, by the way, but I'm posting it here to see if anyone is remotely upset by that characterization of Serial, and just how touchy people can become about culture. It might make the furor over the cartoons more easy to understand.

posted by Nevin at 11:52 AM on January 7, in thread 145914



I wonder how many people would be rushing in here to discuss the "context" of this crime had it been a rape?

I wonder how many people would be citing the victims' history of wearing "provocative outfits" or "getting drunk" or "putting themselves in vulnerable positions".

Rape is rape. Murder is murder.

posted by smithsmith at 12:36 PM on January 7, in thread 145914



Wow, both my comments have been deleted, one which agreed with sangermaine and another about acts of violence perpetrated by muslims. The lengths this place goes to to protect muslims who commit atrocities is appalling.

posted by marienbad at 12:38 PM on January 7, in thread 145914



And another deleted - you can't even complain about it on here now. wow. american liberals supporting murderers - what has the world come to.

Manhunt underway - interesting that they can't find them - someone (or someones) are shielding them.

posted by marienbad at 12:44 PM on January 7, in thread 145914




Manhunt underway - interesting that they can't find them - someone (or someones) are shielding them.
posted by marienbad at 12:49 PM on January 7 [+] [!]


Wild-ass speculation with an undercurrent of incitement. Flagged.

posted by lalochezia at 12:53 PM on January 7, in thread 145914



Manhunt underway - interesting that they can't find them - someone (or someones) are shielding them.

posted by marienbad at 12:49 PM on January 7, in thread 145914



interesting that they can't find them - someone (or someones) are shielding them.

For instance?

posted by Rustic Etruscan at 12:54 PM on January 7, in thread 145914



Granted nobody died, but we had a terrorist attack in Colorado on January 6 that doesn't appear to be getting a whole lot of attention.

posted by Joey Michaels at 12:53 PM on January 7, in thread 145914



Granted nobody died, but we had a terrorist attack in Colorado on January 6 that doesn't appear to be getting a whole lot of attention.

posted by Joey Michaels at 12:53 PM on January 7, in thread 145914



(I bring up the NAACP bombing primarily in response to Golden Eternity's link - I meant to include this statement in the same comment but forgot and didn't want to add it after the fact in this fast moving conversation)

posted by Joey Michaels at 12:59 PM on January 7, in thread 145914



drown out the little voice saying: "false flag, false flag, false flag ..."

If the CCTV was 'not working', or they don't find the killers, or if they find a couple of amateurish guys wholly unlike the trained killers seen today, then this may well be a false flag operation - of which there are dozens of previous examples.

posted by colie at 1:12 PM on January 7, in thread 145914



of which there are dozens of previous examples

Care to name, say, your top five from the past 15 years?

posted by yoink at 1:18 PM on January 7, in thread 145914



If the CCTV was 'not working', or they don't find the killers, or if they find a couple of amateurish guys wholly unlike the trained killers seen today, then this may well be a false flag operation - of which there are dozens of previous examples.

So the lesson from this comment is that if the mods blow away your previous false flag turd, you can just fling it again until it sticks.

posted by Behemoth at 1:30 PM on January 7, in thread 145914



symbioid, give it a fucking rest, man. You are throwing up so many red herrings it's ridiculous. When Fidel Cashflow asks, "Should only tasteful satire be protected speech?" he's not asking for your take on what the government's stance should be, he's saying that there is the blood of twelve people running through the streets of Paris and that means today the cost of speech was life and that is tremendously wrong.

So you know, let me be totally clear on this. You can take your factionalism, religious and ethnic divides, etc. and - in this particular situation - shove them up your ass. Because there is a shadow over this particular conversation and you are totally trolling us by not acknowledging its overwhelming importance. One might even go so far as to say this is an incredibly important time to be clear about what you are not open-minded about.

But if you want to say this is the wake-up call that we needed in order to start this conversation, then by God, go ahead and say it. Fucking go for it. But don't call the rest of us dense for looking at this as a blatant affront on liberty, and invoking certain well-established social principles that serve to shape Western civilization to essentially say, "No matter what these people printed, this is categorically wrong, and we will not be intimidated." Goddamnit.

posted by phaedon at 2:19 PM on January 7, in thread 145914



BY QUESTIONING THE WISDOM OF THE ACT OF THE VICTIMS I'M CLEARLY VICTIM BLAMING

Yes, now you have it.

posted by the bricabrac man at 4:15 PM on January 7, in thread 145914



Lots of Frislamic folks getting ass fed hummus as I type this, I reckon.

posted by Renoroc at 5:18 PM on January 7, in thread 145914



Actually the #NotAllMuslims analogy to #NotAllMen analogy fits perfectly, desjardins.

#NotAllMen = #NotAllMenWhoComplainAboutRapeConversations
#NotAllMuslims = #NotAllMuslimsWhoComplainAboutMuhammadCartoons

Both critique people who seek to avoid justified criticism of an ideology by incorrectly claiming personal injury : aspects of rape culture and Islamic fundamentalism.

posted by jeffburdges at 5:27 PM on January 7, in thread 145914



As an example of that, I haven't heard any calls for apologies from white men, and arguments for white men's collective guilt, and, in fact, not much of anything at all, regarding the fact that an NAACP headquarters was bombed yesterday by a white man.

Somehow, another attempted terrorist attack has gone largely unnoticed. It is very strange how this happens sometimes.

posted by homunculus at 5:45 PM on January 7, in thread 145914



Could we maybe stop with the NAACP derail?

posted by roomthreeseventeen at 5:46 PM on January 7, in thread 145914



I'll wager the bombers of the NAACP office have a connection to law enforcement. At minimum the attack was stirred up by the right-wing's pro-cop anti-black tirade after Ferguson.

posted by jeffburdges at 5:53 PM on January 7, in thread 145914



A history of racist and xenophobic cartoons does not "justified criticism of an ideology" make.

Especially since Muslims themselves have come under fire from Muslims and non-Muslims alike for critiquing their religion without this much solidarity.


Sorry, but this is not a statement of facts, it is her opinion. divabat may post emphatic opinions, delivered with great assurance, but that does not make her right. And if she gets mad that others emphatically state opinions at odds with hers, that is too bad.

posted by feste at 6:03 PM on January 7, in thread 145914



That was a ridiculous deletion.

posted by mlis at 6:15 PM on January 7, in thread 145914



Actually the #NotAllMuslims analogy to #NotAllMen analogy fits perfectly, desjardins.

excellent mansplaining, jeffburdges. you bear our white man's burden with grace.

Oops, sorry. strike that. invert. thanks.

posted by mwhybark at 6:23 PM on January 7, in thread 145914



That mockery of the pain and trauma of still not found kidnapped young schoolgirls is dickish.

posted by infini at 1:30 PM on January 7, in thread 145914



A reminder that we grow our own crazies at home too:

posted by hank at 6:49 PM on January 7, in thread 145914



What do you mean we? We're all in this together. This isn't us and them.

posted by ODiV at 6:55 PM on January 7, in thread 145914



The extremists on both sides are on collusion against the middle.

human centipede

posted by stbalbach at 8:38 AM on January 7, in thread 145914



Thursday, November 12, 2015

Another long-time user quits

I note that in the instances I have read about women on campus being raped, more often than not they mention they had blacked out or were passed out, etc. when the assault took place. First question, then, is how old is the guy, the girl, and what is the drinking age, and where did the incident take place--that is, on or off campus.

I worried about such goings on when my daughter was at college--she graduated last year--but worried much less when I learned that she disliked large drinking gatherings, was careful with what she did drink.

posted by Postroad at 8:51 AM on November 11, in thread 154618



As a man who hasn't been south of 6'2" or 250 lbs in years, my direct action is to tackle guys who are wearing football jerseys and smash them into the ground. If anyone complains, my defense is, "Come on! Dressed like that, he was asking for it."

posted by ricochet biscuit at 8:51 AM on November 11, in thread 154618



Clearly and reasonably men carry the legal and moral responsibility for the vast majority of sexual assaults and rape. If there is mutual intoxication/diminished capacity I fail to see how a woman who is intoxicated, and has diminished capacity, is able to give or withhold informed consent as if she was sober . One should reasonable assert that an intoxicated male carries the significant share of responsibility and culpability but I really do not see how that waives contributory, though passive, negligence on the part of the woman. If a driver is drunk it is not prudent to get in the car--but are you more or less likely to get in the car if you are sober or intoxicated. I am seriously trying not to set this up as blaming the victim but I see few other situations when there is mutual diminished capacity that some culpability, though not necessarily proportionate,is not assigned or absolved to both parties. I am only talking about when there is mutual diminished capacity. It is usually prudent to be substantially sober or only slightly buzzed as there is increased risk with any episode of intoxication (falling, fighting, spending money, throwing up, other socially offensive behaviors or sexual victimization or impropriety). But once again, I am not referring to one party intoxication which can be blatantly exploitative.

posted by rmhsinc at 1:52 PM on November 11, in thread 154618



whether the men raping me were sober or drunk, it at no time felt like an accident or happenstance or something he fell into. if a man's diminished capacity is a factor in him raping someone, that was in him all along. his victims are not culpable in any way for his crime of anger and entitlement.

posted by nadawi at 2:01 PM on November 11, in thread 154618



Can we just agree that getting drunk at parties is stupid and horrible?

Yep, men can get sexually aggressive when they are drunk. Because people act like shit when they are drunk, and sexual aggression is just one of a multitude of ways in which people can act like shit.

We can adopt better consent standards, hold perpetrators accountable, etc, and it will probably reduce rape. But as long as throngs of people gather at parties with the intention to drink, screw, or bask in the tension of others doing so, shitty things will happen. I basically won't go to any event like that anymore—I'm fucking done with them. I'm sick or pretending they are fun, or watching people treat each other like shit and laughing it off because woohoo that's what people do when they are drunk.

posted by andrewpcone at 2:22 PM on November 11, in thread 154618



Well, it was interesting to wake up to being characterized as a straight woman with homophobia issues. That was pretty choice, since the actual perspective I'm coming from is (as Conspire pointed out) that of a queer woman

When you sideline your minority status to gang up with the majority you belong to to slag off another minority, you are committing the exact same sin the article objects to re: privilege. Sorry for assuming you were straight; I just figured a lesbian would have a better handle on it, since hatred of gay men has a way of spilling over.

So, seriously, what is your excuse for being so goddamned homophobic that every time a gay man pisses you off, that gets filed in the Gay Men Are Terrible file? Do you do the same thing with Black people and Jews? That sort of thing is not a "pet peeve," it's prejudice.

Your experiences are not sacred. Sharing your cherry-picked worst interactions with a minority group negatively impacts innocent people. Take some responsibility.

posted by Sys Rq at 8:02 AM on November 12, in thread 23911



Bro, I was saying that gay men have a cultural problem with a very specific form of misogyny. If that's homophobic, is there a way to criticize gay men in what is theoretically my own goddamn community that isn't? Intersectionality is a fucking thing, and given that we're both queer and you're trying to silence me from discussing my experiences... Well, that leaves a bad taste in my mouth.

posted by sciatrix at 8:09 AM on November 12, in thread 23911



I think it's perfectly valid, and if you disagree you can state your reasons rather than using insults.

As I said before, the message seems to be "It's deplorable to restrain the media until it's done by someone we agree with".

posted by Sangermaine at 9:41 AM on November 12, in thread 154647



It's funny that this is exactly what conservatives say when railing about the mainstream media and trying to control the media narrative. We generally laugh at them for this.

Surely you know what a shitty rhetorical device this is. Can you not do it here?

posted by maxsparber at 9:39 AM on November 12, in thread 154647



from the fpp link:

> That these issues have now been subsumed in a debate over political correctness and free speech
> on campus—important but largely separate subjects—is proof of the self-serving deflection to
> which we should be accustomed at this point.

"Self-serving deflections." That's a patent assumption. "Self-serving", maybe, maybe not, proof one way or the other is required, it is illegitimate just to assume it. "Deflections", not--except in the sense that they divert attention from those aspects of a fraught situation which some groups wish were the only subjects of the, heh, conversation, toward other aspects of the same fraught situation which the same groups do not wish to think about. The only proof offered is the unsupported assertion that "political correctness and free speech on campus" are "largely separate subjects" from racial recrimination and self-righteous backlash, a patent and tendentious falsehood. In fact all of these are most intimately, inextricably intertwined. If that kind of blanket, unsupported assertion is all you got, you got nothing. (Except wishful thinking.)


from this thread, supra:

> That Kristof article falls into the same disingenuous pattern that Cobb points out

"Disingenuous," another patent assumption. Do you really imagine Kristof is arguing for beliefs he does not sincerely hold? Because that's what disingenuous is. Pics or it didn't happen.

Yes, yes, I know where I am. Only two kinds here, people who agree with us and people who are arguing disingenuously. To believe that is an intellectual illness; one cannot have substantive conversation with the intellectually ill.

posted by jfuller at 9:49 AM on November 12, in thread 154647



and we're now back to the original thread.

maybe time to put this MeTa to bed?


You're upset that this discussion is taking place. Are you therefore taking it upon yourself to derail the conversation so it can be closed? Because as a lurker watching what's going on, that's what it seems like.

posted by zarq at 10:51 AM on November 12, in thread 23911



> if I'm not the one with skin in the fight, I'm not the one who gets to dictate the tactics.

Then--department of unintended consequences--folks should be somewhat more diffident about announcing "everyone is racist" because that gives everyone skin in the fight.

posted by jfuller at 11:52 AM on November 12, in thread 154647



> [One comment deleted. jfuller, please just skip this thread.]

Done. I find that the mere pleasure of having an ultra-low user number is no longer enough to make me want to associate myself with the kind of Victorian-foundation-garment site Metafilter has become. Apologies to those who are legitimately my friends here (especially to Katjusa Roquette, to whom I just this minute finished linking to (friend)) and those who were pleased to link to me, especially b33j.

posted by jfuller at 3:19 PM on November 12, in thread 154647